Thursday, September 01, 2005

Mis-Reporting on Charter Schools

An editorial appeared in the local paper lauding the success of a KIPP charter school. And the number are gaudy, no doubt. Huge percentages of proficient kids, especially math, huge API, etc. Good for them.

Two huge weaknesses of the editorial, which is layed-out like a feature news, contains a hard lede, and is all over misleading in that vein:

1) They have 73 kids, and there model does not allow additional growth within grade levels. So, 73.

2) The newspaper ran their numbers alongside that of entire Districts. Again, 73 kids. Tightly controlled environments and corporate money. It is disingenuous to compare results in that way, when no District could support that style of education for all students. [EDIT: something they freely admit] Seventy-three kids, many of whom, if the downward trend in the community schools wherein those students would otherwise have attended are to be believed, probably would have succeeded anywhere.

The kind of typically sloppy reporting charter schools benefit from.

1 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

Tragedy Knows No Boundary
Reading and viewing online news coverage of the Katrina hurricane disaster in the US over recent days, I'm just awed by the sheer scale of so many people - thousands according to many news reports - losing ...
Great Blog! If you have time see my ##work at home## related site. enjoy! It pretty much covers ##work at home## related stuff.

4:22 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home